Can't find the items you're looking for?

Click below to begin your custom themed order

Custom Order Form

Shop By Item

Message us if you need help finding an item

3D Letters

Banners

Cake Toppers

Cupcake Toppers
Party Cups
Favors

Chip Cans

Coloring Boxes
Flowers
Gable Boxes
Milestone Banners
Digital

Popular Themes

Digital
Blues
Muted Rubble
Farmer Mouse
Vintage Parks
Stranger Kids
Construction
Minions
Neverland
Sports

Hedgehog

Lumberjack

Gingerbread
Hole In One
Small World
Coco
Spidey

CFA

Pink Halloween
Encanto

Party Packages

Party Package A

From $55.00

Party Package B

From $80.00

Party Package C

$115.00

Party Package D

From $109.00

Party Package E

From $190.00

Party Package F

$110.00

View all

New Arrivals

Underpants Hero Cake Topper

From $30.00

Poke 3D Letters/Numbers

From $15.00

School Grad Cake Topper

From $30.00

School Days Prop: First/Last Day Interchangeable

From $35.00

Fresh 90s Cupcake Toppers

From $24.00

Fresh 90s Centerpiece Boxes

From $100.00

Dark Bat Cupcake Toppers

From $24.00

Dark Bat 3D Letters/Numbers

From $15.00

Keep Swimming Cake Topper

From $32.00

Custom Centerpiece Boxes

From $112.00

Pineapple Under the Sea Cake Topper

$30.00

Bee-Day Cake Topper

$28.00

Wonder Woman Cake Topper

From $30.00

PJ Cake Topper

From $30.00

View all

Blues

Blues Cake Topper

From $30.00

Blues Cupcake Toppers

From $24.00

Blues 3D Letters

From $17.00

Blues Chip Cans: Pail and Shovel

From $42.00

View all

Muted Rubble

Muted Rubble Cake Topper

From $30.00

Muted Rubble Banner

From $25.00

View all

Farmer Mickey

Farmer Mouse Favor Boxes

From $32.00

Farmer Mouse Cake Topper

$30.00

Farmer Mouse Party Cups

From $24.00

View all

Construction

Construction Cake Topper

From $30.00

Construction Banner

From $25.00

Construction Party Cups

From $24.00

Construction 3D Letters

From $17.00

View all

Lumberjack

Lumberjack Banner

From $25.00

Lumberjack 3D Letters

From $17.00

Lumberjack Cake Topper

$30.00

Lumberjack Milestone Banner

$47.00

Baby Lumberjack Cake Topper

$30.00

Sale

Lumberjack One Stickers (PNG)

$4.99 $5.00

View all

Neverland Theme

Neverland Cake Topper

From $29.00

Neverland 3D Letters/Numbers

From $17.00

Neverland Favor Boxes

From $32.00

Sale

Neverland Banner

From $25.00 $27.00

Neverland Milestone Banner

$42.00

View all

Sports

Sports Cake Topper

From $30.00

Sports Theme Favor Boxes

From $32.00

Sports Banner

From $25.00

Vintage Parks

Vintage Park Cake Topper

From $32.00

Vintage Park Banner

From $25.00

Vintage Park Milestone Banner

$47.00

Vintage DW Cake Topper

From $32.00

Vintage DW Banner

From $25.00

Vintage Park 3D Letters/Numbers

From $15.00

Vintage Friends Cake Topper

From $30.00

View all

Groovy

Groovy Cake Topper

From $32.00

Groovy Milestone Banner

$47.00

Groovy Cupcake Toppers

From $24.00

Groovy Banner

From $25.00

View all

Hedgehog Theme

Hedgehog Cake Topper

From $32.00

Sale

Hedgehog Banner

From $25.00 $30.00

Hedgehog Favor Boxes

From $32.00

Hedgehog Coloring Boxes

From $32.00

Hedgehog Cupcake Toppers

From $22.00

Hedgehog 3D Letters/Numbers

From $17.00

View all

Gingerbread

Gingerbread House Favor Boxes

From $32.00

Gingerbread House Cake Topper

From $30.00

NBC

Nightmare Cake Topper

From $30.00

Nightmare Flowers

From $47.00

Sally Cake Topper

From $30.00

Nightmare Banner

From $25.00

View all

Pink Halloween

If you do not see your item within a theme/collection please use Custom Theme request listings

Pink Halloween Banner

From $25.00

Pink Halloween Candy Tube Boxes

From $50.00

Pink Halloween Cake Topper

From $32.00

Pink Halloween 3D Letters/Numbers

From $17.00

Pink Halloween Favor Boxes

From $32.00

View all

Hole In One

Hole in One 3D Letters/Numbers

From $17.00

Hole In One Milestone Banner

$47.00

Hole In One Banner

From $25.00

Hole In One Favor Boxes

From $32.00

Hole In One Cake Topper

From $30.00

View all

Spidey

Spiderman Cake Topper

$30.00

Spiderman Party Cups (12 ct.)

From $26.00

Spidey & Friends Banner

From $25.00

Spiderman Cupcake Toppers

From $22.00

Spidey and Friends Cake Topper

From $30.00

View all

Coco

Coco Cake Topper

From $30.00

Coco Banner

From $25.00

Sugar Skull Flowers: 11 Pc Set

$107.00

Coco Melon Cake Topper

From $28.00

Coco Flower Set

From $87.00

Coco 3D Letters/Numbers

From $17.00

View all

Let customers speak for us

from 1029 reviews

Couldn't have dreamed up anything better!

Emily Huntley
Custom Favor Boxes
Perfect in every way!

Melissa is so incredibly talented. The level of detail in every design is amazing. I requested a custom Stranger Things banner and it was perfect. I couldn’t be happier. I’m a repeat customer and will always go to Melissa for any of my party needs. Make sure to book way in advance because she does get busy. That’s how in demand she is! Everything about my order was perfect! I’m so happy.

Jillian P.
Custom Banner
Perfection!

I am kicking myself for having waited so long to order something from you lol. The topper was amazing. I ordered it with lights, completely forgot about the lights so we haven't lit it up yet. But the details and just the patience that went into making this is stellar. I will definitely be a repeat customer! Can't wait to order those wall flowers! Those will be for me though lol. TY SOOO MUCH!

Cecilie Vargas
Jurassic World Cake Topper
Two Infinity & Beyond

We were not able to have the big Two Infinity and Beyond Toy Story themed birthday party that I wanted to have for my son, we did have a small family party and the “Two Infinity & Beyond” cake topper I received was incredible!!! My 2 year old son loved it, especially with the flashing lights!!! And everyone that attended raved about how cute the cake topper was!!! I plan on keeping the topper and putting it into my son’s baby book! :-)

Meghan Silva
To Infinity & Beyond Cake Topper
Best service ever

I can not express how wonderful she is! She’s precise tedious and loving with her work and it shows!

Brittaney Russell
Custom Cupcake Toppers
Always amazing!

I have asked magicalkraftsbymk to create custom pieces for multiple of my kids birthdays and she never disappoints :)

Whitney Combs
Custom Cupcake Toppers
Vintage Disneyland Cake Topper

The only place I will order my cake toppers! Quality and creativity is always AMAZING!!

Bianca
Vintage Park Cake Topper
Beautiful!!!!

This banner for my son’s Two Infinity and Beyond birthday party turned out better than I could have hoped. It looks incredible and I can’t wait for his party to hang it up and have everyone admire it.

Terri
Space Ranger Banner

It was beyond my expectations.
Loved it 😍

Areli Burgos
Baby Dinosaur Cake Topper
Truly Magical

She does such beautiful work. As a crafter myself i know how much work and passion goes into each detail. I love supporting other crafters and especially those like you who are truly talented and genuine. Thank You, Thank You, Thank You!!!! My daughter LOOOOOOOVED her topper.

Paige Carlock
Aurora Cake Topper
Skye cake topper

Seriously the coolest cake topper. Spend the little extra on the lights it's so worth it.

Bianca
Police Dog Cake Topper
Perfect for Cars party

The seller was so easy to work with and answered all of my questions so quickly. The banner & cake topper matched our party decor perfectly and looked so great! I’ll definitely be ordering here again!

Mandy J
Cars Banner

Beautiful! Came on time and the craftmanship is amazing. Thank you!

Kelli
Magicalkraftsbymk

I got this for my sons 11th birthday, I reached out to the shop owner to see if a two number item would fit and be possible to make, the owner was fast to reply and did an amazing job on it. I highly recommend!

Karen
Neverland Cake Topper

I’ve been following this small shop since 2017 and finally decided to order from her for my daughters birthday party this year. She blew my expectations with these bubble guppies toppers! Wonderful customer service and such High quality items. Highly recommend

Shyan
Magicalkraftsbymk